The Ultimate Petplan vs. Healthy Paws Comparison

Our Review Method

I’ll be diving deep into each provider's plans, coverage, and pricing. For customer service, I’ll be checking trusted review sources and the customer support options each provider has.

Overall Winner

	Petplan	Healthy Paws
Coverage	4.5	4
Costs	3.5	4.5
Plans	4.5	4
Customer service	2.5	5
Overall Winner	3.75	4.38

Healthy Paws is the preferred choice here. It offers excellent customer service and low costs, but Petplan offers the flexibility some people need.

Petplan

Here, I’ll be covering everything Petplan has to offer. I’ll be going over their plans, rates, and customer service options.

Petplan prides itself on its coverage. Unlike other providers, exam fees, online vet visits, and dental work are all covered. Customers Advocate compared Petplan to other top providers and concluded that it provides the most comprehensive coverage.
Petplan only allows you to purchase one plan, so keep that in mind when comparing costs. The plan they offer includes complete coverage. You can tweak the annual rates, limits, and reimbursement, though. With a yearly deductible of $500, an unlimited limit, and 70% reimbursement, your one-year-old golden retriever would cost around $51.04 a month.
Petplan has a FAQ section that answers some of the fundamental questions that customers have. To speak with a live representative, you can call them or use the live chat bubble. You can talk to a “Sales” and “Existing Policy Support” team. Once you connect with an agent, Petplan will show you a phone number you can call to speak to the agent.

You may also like the following comparison: PetPlan VS PetsBest

Healthy Paws

healthy paws comparison

Healthy Paws has high customer satisfaction and low costs but lacks in plan customization. Here are the factors you should consider when choosing this provider.

It covers accidents, illnesses, conditions, prescription medicine, cancer, and more. It doesn't cover pre-existing conditions, spaying, and neutering, preventive care, vaccines, or teeth cleaning.
It has incredibly fair prices. If you have an annual deductible of $500, unlimited limit, and 70% reimbursement, your one-year-old golden retriever can expect a monthly premium of around $32.
The customer service is top-notch, according to Customers Advocate. You can talk to a customer support agent via phone.

You may also like the following comparison: HealthyPaws VS Embrace

Petplan vs. Healthy Paws Comparison Chart

Service	Petplan	Healthy Paws
Animals covered	Dogs and cats	Dogs and cats
Coverage type	Accident, illness, holistic therapies, dental	Accident, illness, and routine care
Costs	Around $51	Around $32
Waiting periods	15 days-6 months	15 days-12months
Network size	The United States and Canada	The United States, or while visiting Canada
Annual limits	$5,000-unlimited	Unlimited
Deductibles	$250-$500	$100-$500
Reimbursement amounts	70%-90% of the actual cost	70%-90% of the actual cost
Customer service	Live chat, phone	Phone
Additional services	Risk-free cancellations up to 30 days	Mobile app for speedy claim payouts

Our Honest Opinion About Healthy Paws

I’m confident with choosing this provider due to the high rate of customer satisfaction. I’d choose this provider over others because I know my pet will receive the best care at a low price. This is the reason I recommend this provider for your pet insurance.

Still Not Sure Which One to Choose?

I understand that picking the right pet insurance provider can be challenging. As a pet owner, pet insurance is an important decision. Check out our other pet provider comparisons to be informed of all the leading pet insurance providers so that you can feel comfortable with your choice.